OAIN 2075 - Warning Failure and Surprise Attack

OAIN 2075 · Spring semester 2025-2026

Language of tuition
English
Course type
Cours séminaire
Number of hours
24
Credits
6

Information

Description

***UPDATED for 2025/26***

This course offers students the opportunity to consider an important aspect of the study of intelligence: surprise attack. This is one of the most widely considered aspects in the academic study of intelligence and an area where valuable lessons can be learnt. The course will comprise 6 sessions, each of which will include lecture, seminar and group work elements. The course begins with a session on the relationship between the intelligence and policy communities, and then proceeds to discuss a variety of issues, including generic issues to do with warning failure surprise attack. The course also includes sessions related to the converse of this - focusing on intelligence success, for instance – and throughout will include both historical and contemporary examples.

LEARNING OUTCOMES

  • An appreciation of the way in which intelligence plays a role in governmental affairs
  • A critical engagement with the methodological issues associated with the study of intelligence, within the wider context of governmental decision-making
  • An ability to engage critically with the literature on the subject, and to undertake primary, independent research

PROFESSIONAL SKILLS

  • Independent research
  • Critical thinking
  • Applied history
  • Teamworking and leadership
  • Presentation skills

Prerequisites

N/A

Teaching format

Feedback and feed-forward will be a consistent element of this course. The classes will by hybrid lecture and discussions, with consistent interactivity and feedback. The mid-term essay will be an opportunity to provide direct feedback that will support students in preparing for their second piece of assessed work.

Assessment

Students will be assessed by

  • One, individual, mid-term essay
  • One, group project, generating a report on a case study of their chosing
  • Mid-term essay is 50% of mark
  • Final written group project is 50% of mark

Workload

  • In Class Presence: 2 hours a week / 24 hours a semester
  • Online learning activities:
  • Reading and Preparation for Class: 60 hours a semester
  • Research and Preparation for Group Work: 40 hours a semester
  • Research and Writing for Individual Assessments: 26 hours a semester

Readings

Main readings 4

  1. 1. Dahl, E. J., Intelligence and Surprise Attack: Failure and Success from Pearl Harbor to 9/11 and Beyond (Georgetown University Press)

  2. 2. Gronning & Mikalsen. (eds) Contemporary Intelligence Warning Cases (Edinburgh University Press)

  3. 3. Gill & Phythian, Intelligence in an insecure world (Polity books)

  4. 4. Robert Jervis, Why Intelligence fails: Lessons from the Iranian Revolution and the Iraq war (Cornell university press)

Further readings 2

  1. 5. Betts, Richard K, "Analysis, War, and Decision: Why Intelligence Failures Are Inevitable." World Politics 31, no. 2 (Oct. 1978)

  2. 6. Jensen, Mark A. "Intelligence Failures: What Are They Really and What Do We Do About Them?" Intelligence and National Security 27, no. 2 (Apr. 20112)

Teaching units

Unit no.Unit type Teaching unitsTeachers Number of hoursCredits
53837Cours séminaire Warning Failure and Surprise Attack Huw DYLAN246

Teachers

  • Huw DYLAN

In the curricula

Contacts and resources

Contact
YOUNÈS Myriam